How do they compare?
| Carrylist | Apple Reminders | |
|---|---|---|
| US price | Free for one adult. Household sharing $3.49 a month or $24.99 a year | Free, built into iPhone and iPad |
| Ads | No | No |
| Devices | iPhone and iPad, iOS 26 or later | iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch, Mac and iCloud.com |
| Sharing with another adult | One other adult with Household. The invited adult pays nothing | Free. Everyone on the list needs an Apple Account |
| Items on set weekdays | Yes. Routines add an item on chosen weekdays | Each reminder repeats on its own schedule |
| Fresh checklist each day | Yes. Each day has its own packing record | No. A repeating reminder returns for its next date. Other items stay completed |
| Printed list to items | Yes. Scan a photo or paste a message, free | Not as separate items. Scanned text goes into one reminder |
| Templates | Yes. Save a bag as a template | Yes. Save any list as a template |
When is Apple Reminders the better choice?
- You want sharing to cost nothing, or more than two people on the list.
- You need a Mac, Apple Watch or browser as well as iPhone and iPad.
- You want location alerts, such as a reminder when you get in the car.
- Your list is short and the same every day.
When is Carrylist the better choice?
- You pack different items on different weekdays, such as PE kit on Tuesday.
- You want every morning to start with nothing checked, without clearing a list.
- You want to see which adult packed an item and who is taking the bag.
- You want a reminder 30 minutes before the bag leaves only if something is unpacked.
- You want to turn a printed or emailed school list into items.
Can I use Apple Reminders as a school bag checklist?
- Make a list for the bag and add each item.
- Give items that change by day their own repeat, such as weekly on Tuesday.
- Save the list as a template to start a new bag from it.
- Share the list with the other adult from the list's share button.
Items without a repeat stay completed after you check them, so clear or uncheck them before the next day.
The short version
Apple Reminders is best for all-Apple families who want a free shared list and will set each repeat themselves. Carrylist is best for parents packing several bags on set days who want a second adult to see what is packed and who has the bag.
Compare all seven apps or see what Carrylist costs. Other comparisons: Google Keep and Cozi Family Organizer.
Try Carrylist with tomorrow's bag
Get Carrylist freeUnlimited solo use. Free.
For iPhone and iPad. iOS 26 or later.
Sources
Checked against each company's own pages and App Store listings on October 17, 2026. Facts about Daycare Bag Checklist and School Bag Checklist come from their App Store listings. Features and prices change. Report an outdated fact.